Diamond shapes that look biggest for their carat weight

By HeyGema™ · Updated

In short

At the same weight, Marquise has the most face-up area in our chart (+16% against a round), then Oval and Emerald cut. The ranking is the same at every weight.

Round
6.5 mm
Oval
8.0 x 5.5 mm
Cushion
5.6 x 5.6 mm
Princess
5.5 x 5.5 mm
Emerald cut
7.0 x 5.0 mm
Asscher
5.5 x 5.5 mm
Radiant
6.5 x 5.0 mm
Pear
8.5 x 5.5 mm
Marquise
10.4 x 5.2 mm
Heart
6.5 x 6.5 mm
Trillion
7.0 x 7.0 mm
Baguette
8.0 x 4.0 mm
= 2 mm in every picture above
A 1 carat diamond in 12 shapes, to the same scale.

Shapes ranked by face-up size at 1 carat

Face-up area is how much of the stone you see from above. It is not the same as weight, since depth and the shape of the outline change it.

1
Shape: Marquise
Length x width at 1 ct: 10.4 x 5.2 mm
Face-up vs round: +16%
Looks like a round of: 1.25 ct
2
Shape: Oval
Length x width at 1 ct: 8.0 x 5.5 mm
Face-up vs round: +6%
Looks like a round of: 1.09 ct
3
Shape: Emerald cut
Length x width at 1 ct: 7.0 x 5.0 mm
Face-up vs round: +4%
Looks like a round of: 1.06 ct
4
Shape: Round
Length x width at 1 ct: 6.5 mm
Face-up vs round: reference
Looks like a round of: 1 ct
5
Shape: Baguette
Length x width at 1 ct: 8.0 x 4.0 mm
Face-up vs round: -2%
Looks like a round of: 0.97 ct
6
Shape: Radiant
Length x width at 1 ct: 6.5 x 5.0 mm
Face-up vs round: -2%
Looks like a round of: 0.96 ct
7
Shape: Pear
Length x width at 1 ct: 8.5 x 5.5 mm
Face-up vs round: -3%
Looks like a round of: 0.96 ct
8
Shape: Princess
Length x width at 1 ct: 5.5 x 5.5 mm
Face-up vs round: -8%
Looks like a round of: 0.88 ct
9
Shape: Trillion
Length x width at 1 ct: 7.0 x 7.0 mm
Face-up vs round: -14%
Looks like a round of: 0.8 ct
10
Shape: Cushion
Length x width at 1 ct: 5.6 x 5.6 mm
Face-up vs round: -14%
Looks like a round of: 0.8 ct
11
Shape: Asscher
Length x width at 1 ct: 5.5 x 5.5 mm
Face-up vs round: -16%
Looks like a round of: 0.78 ct
12
Shape: Heart
Length x width at 1 ct: 6.5 x 6.5 mm
Face-up vs round: -17%
Looks like a round of: 0.76 ct

What a carat buys in each shape

The last column says a 1 carat stone of that shape faces up like a round of the weight shown. Compare millimeters when you shop, since the same shape varies with its ratio.

Oval
1 ct looks like: 1.09 ct round
2 ct looks like: 2.18 ct round
3 ct looks like: 3.26 ct round
Cushion
1 ct looks like: 0.8 ct round
2 ct looks like: 1.59 ct round
3 ct looks like: 2.39 ct round
Princess
1 ct looks like: 0.88 ct round
2 ct looks like: 1.76 ct round
3 ct looks like: 2.64 ct round
Emerald cut
1 ct looks like: 1.06 ct round
2 ct looks like: 2.11 ct round
3 ct looks like: 3.17 ct round
Asscher
1 ct looks like: 0.78 ct round
2 ct looks like: 1.55 ct round
3 ct looks like: 2.33 ct round
Radiant
1 ct looks like: 0.96 ct round
2 ct looks like: 1.93 ct round
3 ct looks like: 2.89 ct round
Pear
1 ct looks like: 0.96 ct round
2 ct looks like: 1.92 ct round
3 ct looks like: 2.87 ct round
Marquise
1 ct looks like: 1.25 ct round
2 ct looks like: 2.49 ct round
3 ct looks like: 3.74 ct round
Heart
1 ct looks like: 0.76 ct round
2 ct looks like: 1.51 ct round
3 ct looks like: 2.27 ct round
Trillion
1 ct looks like: 0.8 ct round
2 ct looks like: 1.61 ct round
3 ct looks like: 2.41 ct round
Baguette
1 ct looks like: 0.97 ct round
2 ct looks like: 1.94 ct round
3 ct looks like: 2.91 ct round

Questions

Marquise, then Oval and Emerald cut, at the same carat weight in our chart. Long, thin shapes spread weight over more face-up area.
An oval of 1 carat is 8.0 x 5.5 mm and faces up +6% against a round (6.5 mm). See round vs oval diamond size.
Heart has the least face-up area, -17% against a round.

More size charts